Loading...
You are here:  Home  >  News  >  Flood  >  Current Article

N.D. lawmaker demands answers from Corps

By   /   June 10, 2011  /   8 Comments

The chairman of the North Dakota House Natural Resource Committee has asked the Army Corps of Engineers to explain the operational decisions in the months leading up to the flood on the upper basin of the Missouri River.

In a letter dated June 9, state Rep. Todd Porter requested an explanation for the Corps’ decision to stop releasing water from Garrison Dam at an increased rate from mid-March until May 6. The Mandan lawmaker also wants to know whether any precautions were taken considering the higher-than-average snowpack in the mountains overlooking the river basin, and whether the nesting season for endangered or threatened birds had any effect on the agency’s releases from the dam this spring.

(Photo by William Prokopyk) An aerial view of the Missouri River flood in the Bismarck-Mandan area, taken from a National Guard Blackhawk helicopter June 9.

The day before Porter sent the letter, the Great Plains Examiner published a story that showed the Corps of Engineers had been unwilling to explain why water managers withheld releases from Garrison Dam during a 45-day period between late March and early May.

“Please provide any records regarding the decision to delay Garrison Dam releases and any internal memos/emails discussing the decisions to delay the releases and slow the releases in 2011,” the letter stated.

Earlier this month, the Corps of Engineers began releasing more water from the dam than ever before, pushing the river beyond its capacity and forcing hundreds of homeowners to evacuate their homes along the river. The release rates are expected to reach 150,000 cubic feet per second – the previous record was 65,200 cubic feet per second during the flood of 1975 – and continue at that level into the summer.

Release rates during the period in question ranged between 14,900 cubic feet per second and 19,000 cubic feet per second. During that time, the river was at its seasonal low point, flowing through Bismarck-Mandan at a depth of less than seven feet.

The river is now running at a depth of nearly 18 feet and is expected to rise to about 19.5 feet within the next week or so. Flood stage is 16 feet at the monitoring station at Bismarck-Mandan.

U.S. Sen. John Hoeven noted in a seperate press release that he is pressing the Corps of Engineers to complete a thorough after-action review of the agency’s flood-control protocols. He also asked the agency to allow all of its field agents to have the flexibility they need to help residents fight the flood.

“First and foremost this is about the flood fight, but the Corps has to analyze what happened here, understand what happened, and then develop whatever processes are necessary so that in the future we can prevent this type of event,” Hoeven stated. “I know with Mother Nature you can’t fully prevent anything, but we have got to understand exactly what happened and learn from it.”

    Print    

8 Comments

  1. Charlie says:

    I am actually hoping and praying our safety, homes and livelihood were not compromised becuase of mis-management or asleep at the wheel syndrome which by the way, seems to be sweeping this nation! I am hoping it was all due to Mother Nature flexing her muscles, but don’t think that will be the case. Great coverage Great Plains Examiner. I will be following you as you grow.

    • Ken Anderson says:

      Whenever events of this nature arise there will be always be finger pointing and blame cast. The corps has always been in a tough position in North Dakota, most often with complaints that not enough water is being held back to protect fishing and recreation interests. Lets just hope that the cooler heads prevail and sort out the events before the stone throwing begins.

  2. Kurt W. Webber says:

    Ken:

    Excellent response.

  3. Alex says:

    Stone throwing??? To my understanding nobody has received any kind of punishment for failing to maintain our river levels this summer. By asking for records pertaining to the time period in which the Corps could have, in my opinion should have, been taking precautionary measures to prevent this catastrophe you imply that it is like stoning people? I think that implication is just ridiculous. Im glad somebody is asking questions and am waiting for the answers eagerly. We cant go back in time to change what happened/is happening, but by not investigating what went wrong how would we be able to change protocols to prevent this from happening next year? I say investigate to the fullest extent, find out exactly what was done wrong. It would be irresponsible and ignorant not to.

    “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”

  4. Are Thousands of People Flooded on the Missouri Because of Fish and Bird Habitats? | UNCOVERAGE.net says:

    [...] [...]

  5. ellison2782 says:

    Well said Alex.

  6. Lefty says:

    The stones have been cast and it is those of us who are bearing the financial, physical and psychological burden of this inept management, that are on the receiving end of the stones. Some of us who have had the misfortune to have our fortune in the hands of the irresponsible and unapproachable and untouchable Corp of Engineers leadership, who take no responsibility for the consequences of their actions or lack thereof are entirely sick of all of the bogus, cop out excuses and entirely sick of statements like ” if we had to do it over we would not do anything differently” Come on…really…if you were working for any business in America you would do it differently, that is if you still had a job.
    Solution: Cut the US Army Corps of Engineers budget so severely that 90% of the Corps lose their jobs. Seriously, America could use the savings to help balance the budget and curtail the rate of escalation in the federal deficit and frankly a committee of three with a $200,000 annual budget could have done a better job of managing the Missouri River system of reservoirs which were built for flood control in the 1950′s.
    It is time to get real!

  7. [...] was the only state lawmaker to file a formal request under the federal Freedom of Information Act for copies of e-mails, memos and other correspondence [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

You might also like...

220px-GreenMountainWindFarm_Fluvanna_2004

After lull, ND wind power development picks up

Read More →